Mere hours after I tipped Phil Mustard to be a contender for bigger things, Hampshire captain and future citizen of Germany Shane Warne has jumped on the bandwagon and tipped the Colonel to star for England. Predictably, he likened him to Adam Gilchrist, which must be something of a burden for a wicket-keeper, much in the same way that every England cricketer who showed the merest hint of being able to bat as well as bowl in the last two decades ran the risk of being labelled The New Ian Botham.
While it would be wonderful to uncover a English Gilchrist or Sangakkara, if there isn’t one in the counties then the selectors need to accept another kind of keeper. One option is to simply select the best gloveman, which would be an acceptable strategy if England had sufficient batting from it’s lower orders (a future line-up including Flintoff, Broad and Rashid might allow just such a strategy). Another option would be a keeper who can defend with the bat, rather than attack. Ian Bell didn’t have a good series against India, perhaps because he knew that as soon as Prior came in he was in a race against time to get some runs in before the lower orders got themselves out.
A keeper who could at least block out the bowlers would let the last batsman play his natural game, and be a useful nightwatchman too. England would benefit from a dull but dependable keeper who could reliably score 20 or so runs in an innings, rather than insisting on a run machine who may well not be out there.